A framework by Eli Schwartz

AEO vs SEO: Eli Schwartz on Why AEO Is Mostly SEO

AEO vs SEO comes down to where your brand shows up. SEO gets your pages found and clicked in Google search. AEO, short for answer engine optimization, gets your brand named inside AI answers in ChatGPT, Gemini and Google's AI Mode. Eli Schwartz, author of the book Product-Led SEO, says the work is mostly the same: about 95% of AEO, apart from the marketing, is SEO (AI SEO Show, 2026). What AEO adds is brand, because AI tools name the brands they already know (productledseo.com, 2026).

Our verdict: if SEO already brings you buyers, keep that budget and build your brand. If you are new and have no search traffic yet, also test a few mentions on the sites AI cites.

Cited from real sources 7 min read Written by Published
Best for
Founders and marketers choosing where to spend: Google search or AI answers like ChatGPT
Price
Free to read. Ask Gavel free.

Deciding where your next marketing dollar goes? Ask Gavel free and get what named founders did, with a link to the minute they said it.

Key takeaways

  • SEO and AEO share one base: pages a search engine can read, a clear site layout and structured data. Schwartz says AEO runs on that base (productledseo.com, April 2026).
  • The difference is brand. AI tools name the brands they already trust, so people have to know you before an AI will mention you (productledseo.com, April 2026).
  • Schwartz says traditional SEO still matters far more than AEO. He expects Google to stay the main place people search (Advanced Web Ranking, July 2026).
  • He would not spend SEO time on AI visibility trackers. Ask customers how they found you, and track how well people know your brand (AI SEO Show, April 2026).
  • Ethan Smith agrees the work overlaps. He says to start AEO now and get mentioned on the pages AI cites (Surfer Academy, November 2025).

The difference

AEO vs SEO: Google ranks pages, AI answers name brands

In SEO, you aim for a spot on Google's first page for a set of keywords, then count the clicks. Schwartz says AI answers have no page one. Each answer is shaped by the exact words a person types and the app they use, so two people can get two different answers (productledseo.com, April 2026).

How Schwartz sets AEO and SEO apart in his post AEO is not SEO 2.0 (productledseo.com, April 2026).
Point SEO AEO
Where you show upA list of links on GoogleInside one answer in ChatGPT, Gemini or AI Mode
What you aim forA rank for a keyword, then a clickTo be the source the AI trusts on your topic
What gets you inPages a crawler can read, content and linksThe same base, plus a brand people already name
How you check itSearch Console clicks and rank reportsAsk customers how they found you
You are not trying to rank in an LLM because you need to become the source the model trusts.
Schwartz on what AEO asks of you Read the post

In traditional SEO, a small brand could win a lot of traffic by tuning its pages and buying links. Schwartz says AI models are built to skip those tricks. They lean toward the brands that show up most often across the web (productledseo.com, April 2026).

The argument

Why Schwartz says AEO is mostly SEO

Each time Schwartz calls AEO an extension of SEO, people push back on LinkedIn. His reply is that about 95% of AEO work, apart from the marketing, is SEO. He says you will rarely find a brand named in an AI answer that did not already do well in Google for similar searches (AI SEO Show, 28:16).

The reason is how AI tools read the web. They learn about your site through the same signals SEO has always used: pages a crawler can read, structured data and a clear site layout. A site built on heavy JavaScript with a confusing menu gets skipped or described wrong (productledseo.com, April 2026). The one technical job he would put a lot of effort into is internal linking. He suggests an HTML sitemap in your footer that links to every page on your site (AI SEO Show, 57:54).

He also expects Google to keep its lead, since Android and Chrome give it a reach that ChatGPT cannot match (AI SEO Show, 29:12). So he frames the race as Google against Google. To show up in Google's AI Mode and AI Overviews, he says, follow SEO best practice, then add marketing on top (AI SEO Show, 30:01).

He says traditional SEO "still matters way more than AEO." His example is a summer trip. You ask AI which city to visit, and then you Google the hotels. AI takes the first idea, and search moves to the middle of the trip, where people check and compare (Advanced Web Ranking, 9:50).

What AEO adds

What AEO adds: a brand the AI already knows

The part outside the overlap is marketing. Schwartz writes that "brand recognition is now a prerequisite for a mention," since AI models lean toward the brands named most often. If the world does not know you, he says, an AI will not either (productledseo.com, April 2026).

He does not treat citations as the new backlinks. He says that idea pleases the people who sell links. A high domain score will not get you into an answer if buyers would not expect your brand there (productledseo.com, April 2026).

The right way to build links is to build a brand.
Schwartz on Lenny's Podcast Watch at 1:08:30

Schwartz sees many companies move SEO money into AI tools and AI agencies, and he says not to. If you spend $10,000 a month on SEO, keep spending $10,000 a month on SEO (97th Floor, 27:22). He treats AI visibility as a brand channel you cannot track well, so he would fund any AI test out of the brand budget (97th Floor, 27:43).

The number

Measure AEO by asking customers how they found you

Schwartz has put money into AI visibility startups (AI SEO Show, 43:41). He still would not spend much SEO time on tracking. A visibility score helps little, he says, "if you can't do anything about it or even know if it's accurate" (AI SEO Show, 44:33).

AI answers also change from one ask to the next. Ask ChatGPT the same question twice and you may get two different answers. Schwartz compares prompt tracking to a weather forecast made by looking out one window (productledseo.com, April 2026).

What he tracks instead:

  • Ask each new customer how they found you, and ask about each step on the way, including the first one (productledseo.com, April 2026).
  • For share of voice, run a brand survey that asks people which brands in your category they know. He says AI answers try to copy real life, so the brands people know are the brands AI names (AI SEO Show, 56:10).
  • In Google Search Console, start with impressions and clicks, then look at what those clicks do on your site. He calls that last step the hard part (Shapley Value, 30:14).

How to apply it

Product-led SEO: his answer to chasing AI citations

Product-led SEO is the name of Schwartz's book and of his method. You treat search as a product question and plan pages the way a product manager plans features (Lenny's Podcast, 0:18).

  1. 1

    Be the user first.

    He says this is the step almost everyone misses. At SurveyMonkey, where he spent seven years, many staff had an account and never ran a survey. Use your own product, then write down what a buyer would type when the problem hits (watch at 31:53).

  2. 2

    Name the search, or skip SEO for now.

    If you cannot say what someone will search for when they need you, he says, do not do SEO (watch at 0:36).

  3. 3

    Make every page lead into the product.

    Zapier's pages lead you to connect two apps. At Tinder, city pages showed a lonely reader that they could meet people in their city, then sent them to download the app (watch at 57:00).

  4. 4

    Plan it as a roadmap.

    Swap the SEO task list for a roadmap where each piece builds on the last, the way a product manager would plan it (watch at 8:29).

  5. 5

    Win the follow-up search.

    He expects AI to answer most first questions. SEO's job, he says, is the next step: the more detailed search a person runs after the AI answer (watch at 19:21).

If there is no product journey for it, there's no user journey, it just stops.
Schwartz on why a page must lead somewhere Watch at 57:41

This is why he sees AI citations as the wrong target. He never liked rankings, and he says a ranking should lead to a click. Being cited in an AI answer often leads to no click at all (Prerender.io, 11:51).

Which call fits your case

When to put money into AEO

Keep it in SEO when

  • You can name the searches your buyers type, and they Google before they buy (Lenny's Podcast, 0:36).
  • You already pay for SEO that brings in buyers. Schwartz says to keep that budget whole (97th Floor, 27:22).

Add AEO work when

  • You have a brand budget to test with. Schwartz would pay for AI visibility from that budget (97th Floor, 27:43).
  • Buyers ask AI to pick a tool in your category. Ethan Smith says an early startup can show up in those answers by getting mentioned on other sites (Lenny's Podcast, 0:25).

One case where Schwartz skips SEO for now: a new startup with a small budget. He would run as much paid marketing as you can afford, because it gets you to product market fit faster. A homepage is enough organic work at that stage (Shapley Value, 21:36).

Where to go next:

The sources

Where Schwartz discusses this

Six recordings from 2024 to 2026 and one post. We checked each quote on this page against his words at the link on November 18, 2026.

Where experts disagree

Where operators disagree: run AEO as its own job now, or as SEO plus brand?

Eli Schwartz

says AEO work is mostly SEO, apart from the marketing (AI SEO Show, 2026). He would keep the SEO budget where it is, skip paid AI visibility trackers, and build a brand the AI tools already know.

Ethan Smith

agrees the two overlap and says one plan can cover both (Ahrefs Podcast, 2026). He still wants teams to start AEO now: track the answers, find the pages AI cites for the prompts you care about, and get mentioned on those pages (Surfer Academy, 2025).

They agree on the base and split on the extra work. Smith says a seed-stage startup cannot wait two years for SEO to pay off. A mention on another site, he says, can put it in AI answers sooner (Niklas Buschner, 2026). Schwartz says to keep the SEO budget whole and pay for AI work out of the brand budget (97th Floor, 2026). Our call: a team whose SEO already brings buyers should follow Schwartz. A new startup with no search traffic can test Smith's mentions on the few prompts its buyers ask.

Sources: Schwartz on AEO and SEO (AI SEO Show, 28:16). Smith on one plan for both (Ahrefs Podcast, 23:23) and on mentions for the prompts you care about (Surfer Academy, 54:12). Read Smith's side on Ethan Smith's Answer Engine Optimization.

Stuck on a real call of your own? Gavel answers startup questions with what a named founder did, and links to the minute they said it. Ask Gavel free

New experts every week

Know when the next expert lands.

Gavel adds new operators to the database every week, each one with cited frameworks you can check and a note on where they disagree with the others. You found this page by searching. Get the next one by email instead.

Latest: Ethan Smith on Answer Engine Optimization

One email a week, only when new experts shipped. Unsubscribe with one click. We never sell or share email.

Related frameworks