A framework by Ethan Smith

Answer Engine Optimization: Ethan Smith's Plan for Founders

Answer engine optimization (AEO) is the work of getting your product named in the answers that ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google's AI Overviews write. Ethan Smith, CEO of the marketing agency Graphite, says these tools run a web search and then sum up the pages they find (Mucker Capital, 2026). So you win in two places. You answer every question your buyers ask on your own site, and you get mentioned on the other sites each answer pulls from (Lenny's Podcast, 2025).

Cited from real sources 8 min read Written by Published
Best for
Founders who want ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google's AI answers to name their product, and want a plan they can test
Price
Free to read. Ask Gavel free.

Not sure AEO should be one of your channels yet? Ask Gavel free and get what named founders did, with a link to the minute they said it.

Key takeaways

  • Find the questions your buyers ask. Start from your search terms and your sales calls (Lenny's Podcast, 2025).
  • Answer the whole set on your own pages, including help center pages for rare use cases (Lenny's Podcast, 2025).
  • Get mentioned on the sites the answers already cite. Broad questions are won mostly there (Surfer Academy, 2025).
  • Run the same prompt on each tool about 10 times, and ask new customers how they heard about you (Ahrefs Podcast, 2026).
  • Eli Schwartz disagrees on new brands. He says a name buyers already know now comes before any mention (Product-Led SEO, 2026).

The idea

What answer engine optimization is

Smith splits an AI answer into two parts. One is the model, trained on billions of old web pages. The other is a live web search that the tool runs and then sums up. He works on the search part, because you can change it. Changing what a model learned in training is hard, and you might wait a year to see it (Lenny's Podcast, 20:27).

That is why he says SEO and AEO are almost entirely the same, and you can run one plan for both. Two things shift: you build mentions where SEO built links, and you put more care into your product, pricing and about pages, since buyers ask about them (Ahrefs Podcast, 23:09).

What changes most is how you win a broad question. On Google, the first blue link for "best website builder" wins. In ChatGPT, the answer sums up many sources at once (Lenny's Podcast, 0:09).

You need to get mentioned as many times as possible.
Smith on what wins an AI answer Watch at 0:18

The questions also get longer. Smith calls this the tail: very specific questions, some of them 60 words long, that were probably never typed into Google (AirOps, 18:50). Many have no good answer anywhere yet. Writing pages that answer the tail is the new part of the job (AirOps, 19:00).

A worked example

How ChatGPT picked payroll software for Smith

Smith shows the method on a real search. He asked ChatGPT for the best payroll management software. It searched the web, listed its sources at the bottom, and wrote an answer from them (Mucker Capital, 3:34).

Then he counted names in the cited pages. ADP came up 10 times, Workday 6 times and Gusto twice, and the answer ranked them in that order. He says it is not an exact count, but the pattern was clear: the more the sources mention you, the higher you show up (Mucker Capital, 3:49).

Perplexity did the same thing. It turned his question into a search, then summed up the results (Mucker Capital, 4:27).

The problem

Why AEO matters to a founder now

A buyer asks ChatGPT which tool to use for the job your product does. If the answer names three rivals and not you, that buyer may never reach your site.

Smith says the buyers who come from AI answers are worth more. At Webflow, Graphite saw a 6x gap in conversion rate between visitors from AI answers and visitors from Google search (Lenny's Podcast, 14:46). His guess at why: by the time they click, they have asked several follow-up questions and know what they want (Lenny's Podcast, 15:00).

He does not think Google search is going away. As new tools arrive, the pie gets bigger and Google's slice stays about the same size (Mucker Capital, 27:52).

The tools

How ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google's AI answers differ

All of these tools search and then write, yet they cite different pages. Graphite looked at thousands of questions. About 35% of the pages ChatGPT cited were also in Google's results. For Perplexity it was about 70% (Lenny's Podcast, 36:54).

On Google's side, Smith expects AI Overviews, AI Mode and Gemini to merge into one product, since they do the same job (Niklas Buschner, 52:09). He sees ChatGPT and Google's Gemini far ahead of every other tool (Niklas Buschner, 52:44).

For a startup with 18 months of cash left, he would not spread out. He would focus on ChatGPT, maybe Gemini, and wait on the rest until they get big (Ahrefs Podcast, 54:00).

When it pays

Should an early-stage founder do AEO yet?

Smith tells seed-stage founders to do almost nothing for SEO, beyond ranking for their own brand name. A new site can take two years to rank, and a startup cannot wait that long (Niklas Buschner, 1:45).

He treats AEO another way. Your own site is unlikely to be cited soon, yet another site can mention you tomorrow, and the answer can pick that up (Niklas Buschner, 2:26). So he makes it a light bet on a few questions, not thousands. He says it might be his fifth most important channel (Niklas Buschner, 2:09).

Graphite has SEO charts to show, but Smith says it has no such charts for AEO yet. What he shares about AEO is what he thinks works (Mucker Capital, 1:46).

At seed stage

What Smith would do first at a seed-stage startup

At this stage he would skip the middle of SEO. The only work he would do is getting cited and answering very specific questions (Lenny's Podcast, 40:52).

  • Pick a short list of prompts.

    Work only on a small set of the questions your buyers ask (Niklas Buschner, 2:48).

  • Do the things that do not scale.

    Make YouTube videos and post in Reddit threads. Smith says these can work for a seed-stage company much faster than Google SEO (Mucker Capital, 34:45).

  • Ask small niche sites to mention you.

    Skip the big papers, which you would have to pay. Find the small sites your buyers read, such as The CTO Club for software buyers, and ask them to promote you. He doubts they get many requests like that (Mucker Capital, 22:34).

  • Answer the question nobody has answered.

    He has seen a new company with a narrow AI payments API show up in answers. It showed up because no one else had answered its question (Lenny's Podcast, 14:21).

How to apply it

How to get cited in AI answers, in four steps

Smith's method starts on your own site and then moves to the sites that answers cite (Lenny's Podcast, 21:54).

  1. 1

    Find the questions your buyers ask.

    Chat tools do not say how often a question is asked, so start from your search terms. A keyword like website builder becomes the question what is the best website builder (watch at 23:30). Then pull the questions from your sales calls, support tickets and Reddit. People likely ask chat tools the same ones (watch at 23:55). To see what a rival cares about, export the keywords it pays for from a tool such as Ahrefs, and ask ChatGPT to turn them into questions (watch at 31:36).

  2. 2

    Answer the whole set of questions on your own pages.

    Group related questions on one page, and answer the follow-up questions too. Smith says a page that skips a question will likely not show up for it (watch at 22:39). Sort the wordings into themes in place of one heading each (watch at 45:49). Some headings can be questions, as long as you do not stuff them (watch at 7:54). Plain headings, bullet points, images and schema are enough for AI tools, as long as the page works (watch at 22:10).

  3. 3

    Write help center pages for the odd questions.

    Buyers ask chat tools whether your product can handle their use case. Move your help center from a subdomain to a subdirectory, and link its pages to each other (watch at 61:26). Then add pages for rare questions. Smith once asked which meeting notes tool works with Looker. No help page answered it, though Otter can do it through Zapier. On a question like that, your page can be the only one cited (watch at 61:52).

  4. 4

    Get mentioned on the sites the answers already cite.

    Put the questions you want to win into an answer tracker. See which sites it cites most, and make a plan for each one (Surfer Academy, 19:36). Smith says broad questions are won mostly by mentions on other sites (Surfer Academy, 18:55). In SEO, a link from any good site helps. In his view, a mention helps here only when it sits on a page that is cited for your question (Surfer Academy, 54:12).

You need other people to mention you.
Smith on winning broad questions Watch at 34:38

Off your site

Where AI answers get their sources, and how to get on them

Smith sorts the pages an answer cites into groups, and makes a plan for each group (Lenny's Podcast, 24:11). Some mentions you earn, such as a creator's video about you. Others you own, such as your own video or Reddit comment (AirOps, 34:59).

  • Video sites such as YouTube.

    Make your own videos. Smith sees the most room on YouTube for products like payroll software, since few people make videos about them and AI answers often cite YouTube (AirOps, 38:00). He says the video's title and description matter most (AirOps, 38:53).

  • Forums such as Reddit and Quora.

    Find a thread that shows up in an answer you want. Post as yourself, name your company and give a useful answer. Smith says even five comments like that can be enough (Lenny's Podcast, 18:29).

  • Big media and review sites.

    His example is Dotdash Meredith, the owner of Investopedia and Good Housekeeping. He calls it probably the most cited publisher in AI answers (Lenny's Podcast, 24:42). In one answer he showed, the cited pages came from list posts, YouTube, Reddit, Zapier and G2 (Surfer Academy, 19:45).

  • Blogs and list posts.

    An answer looks for several sources that name the same product. Smith's example is an SEO tool. Write a list post of the best SEO tools, and ask a peer such as Clearscope to write one too. Then each list names the other (Surfer Academy, 34:18). He calls this consensus building (Surfer Academy, 35:00).

Workflows

AEO plays for your situation

  • If your product works with other tools.

    Write about each integration on several pages. His example is Otter and Zoom: a help center page, a feature page, a how-to article, and a page on Zoom's own site about the Otter integration (Niklas Buschner, 60:54). If you are small, write a page about your integration with each big partner, then ask them to write one about you (Surfer Academy, 33:23).

  • If buyers ask AI tools to compare you with rivals.

    Publish your own comparison page. Smith says a company that will not compare itself with rivals leaves its story in the answer to other people (Surfer Academy, 55:39).

  • If your site already has a lot of pages.

    Go back to your top pages and update them with what has changed, before you write new ones (Webflow, 19:03).

Measure it

How to track whether AI answers name you

An AI answer changes from one run to the next. Smith runs the same prompt on each tool about 10 times, then looks at how often you show up and where (Ahrefs Podcast, 52:30). He calls the share of runs where you appear your share of voice (Lenny's Podcast, 37:17). He buys the cheapest answer tracker that does what he needs (Lenny's Podcast, 35:35).

Most AI answers lead to no click. People open a new tab or search your name, and your analytics files that visit as direct or brand search. So Smith measures the two ends. At the start, did you appear in the answer? At the end, ask each new customer how they heard about you (Surfer Academy, 56:48).

Regardless of the channel, I would definitely ask how did you hear about us?
Smith to early-stage founders Watch at 32:39

To test a tactic, he splits his prompts into two groups and leaves one group alone. On the other group he makes one change, such as Reddit comments or a YouTube video. A few weeks later he compares the two (Lenny's Podcast, 44:19). Without the group you left alone, the rise in AI use could make any change look like it worked (AirOps, 42:40).

Limits

Where Smith's AEO method stops working

Works best when

  • Buyers ask long, specific questions about your product that no page answers yet.
  • You can leave a set of prompts alone as a control before you scale a tactic.

Fails when

  • You post on Reddit as if you did not work at the company. Smith calls that spam, and says to pick a channel you control, such as YouTube (watch at 48:20).
  • You copy tactics from blog posts without a test. Smith says to run your own test before you trust any of them (watch at 32:31).

Where to go next:

Questions

Answer engine optimization FAQ

Should I block AI crawlers from my site?

Smith would not block them from reading your site, or your rivals will show up in your place. If you do not want AI firms to train on your pages, block the training bots in robots.txt and let the search bots in (Lenny's Podcast, 42:19).

Can I write AEO pages with AI?

Graphite found that pages written only by AI do not work. AI drafts that a person edits do (Lenny's Podcast, 54:44).

Who should do the AEO work?

Your SEO team, agency or consultant can do the work on your own site. Smith says most SEO people are not good at YouTube and Reddit, so that part may need a community marketer (Lenny's Podcast, 33:01).

The sources

Where Smith discusses this

Seven recordings from 2025 and 2026. We checked each quote on this page against his words at the linked minute on November 18, 2026.

Where experts disagree

Where experts disagree: can a new startup get cited before buyers know its name?

Ethan Smith

says yes. A seed-stage company can show up in an answer as soon as another site mentions it, long before its own site ranks (Niklas Buschner, 2026). He tracks each question by asking it about 10 times on each tool (Ahrefs Podcast, 2026).

Eli Schwartz

puts brand first. In his view, an unknown brand could once win search with a clever plan, and that option is gone: brand recognition now comes before a mention (Product-Led SEO, 2026). He would not spend much on AI visibility tools, since you cannot check if they are right (AI SEO Show, 2026).

Pick by how well buyers know you. If you are new and your buyers ask long, specific questions that no page answers, make Smith's light bet on a few questions and a few mentions. If you compete for broad questions that big brands already own, follow Schwartz and put the money into SEO and your brand first.

Sources: Smith on early-stage companies (Niklas Buschner, 2:26) and on tracking (Ahrefs Podcast, 52:30). Schwartz on brand recognition (AEO is not SEO 2.0, April 2026) and on AI visibility tools (AI SEO Show, 44:20). Read Schwartz's full case in Eli Schwartz on AEO vs SEO.

Stuck on a real call of your own? Gavel answers startup questions with what a named founder did, and links to the minute they said it. Ask Gavel free

New experts every week

Know when the next expert lands.

Gavel adds new operators to the database every week, each one with cited frameworks you can check and a note on where they disagree with the others. You found this page by searching. Get the next one by email instead.

Latest: Ethan Smith on Answer Engine Optimization

One email a week, only when new experts shipped. Unsubscribe with one click. We never sell or share email.

Related frameworks