A pricing method by Madhavan Ramanujam

Monetizing Innovation: Ramanujam's Method for Founders

Monetizing Innovation is a book about how to make money from a new product, by Madhavan Ramanujam and Georg Tacke (2016). Its answer is to design the product around the price. Ask buyers what they would pay before you build. Then pick the features, the plans and the way you charge from their answers. Ramanujam calls the goal product market pricing fit: proof that buyers will pay for the product.

Best for
Founders before launch who want to test what buyers will pay and choose which features to build first
Price
Free to read. Ask Gavel free.

The method in five lessons

  • Talk about price before you build. You will have the price talk with buyers either way, and the only choice is whether it comes before or after launch.
  • Never ask a buyer what you should charge. Pitch the value, then ask which price feels fair, which feels expensive and which is far too much.
  • Use the answers to decide what to build. Ramanujam says you cannot plan a roadmap without them.
  • Build one product for each group of buyers who need, value and pay for different things.
  • Decide how you charge before you decide how much. Charging per mile or per use can matter more than the number.
Cited from real sources 9 min read Written by Founder of Gavel Published

Not sure what your buyers would pay? Gavel answers startup questions with what a named founder did, and links to the minute they said it. Ask Gavel free

Two ways to price a new product

The usual way

Build the product, then put a price on it.

Ramanujam's way

Test the price, then build the product around it.

He calls the usual way spray and pray.

Madhavan Ramanujam on Lenny's Podcast Watch at 18:10

The idea

The core idea of Monetizing Innovation: design the product around the price

That idea is the book's subtitle: How Smart Companies Design the Product Around the Price (watch at 11:03). Ramanujam had spent 15 years at Simon-Kucher, a pricing firm, when he told the story on Lenny's Podcast (watch at 4:11).

The book came from a pattern he kept seeing. Companies spent years on a product, then called his firm for a price plan they needed right away (watch at 8:16). When his team checked, 72% of new products failed to make money, because no one asked early whether buyers would pay (Lenny's Podcast, 2022, watch at 8:58).

He also says the price belongs with the product team. If you design the product around what buyers value and will pay for, the people who design the product have to own the price (watch at 10:52).

The book sorts those failures into four types (watch at 16:25). First Round Review named all four in its November 2016 write-up of his talk (read it here).

  • Feature shock. The product is packed with far too many features.

  • Minivation. The product is right, but the team does not dare to charge the right price.

  • Hidden gem. A product the company should build, but does not, because it is unlike what the company sells today.

  • Undead. A product that should never launch, because it comes back to haunt the company.

If you didn't put pricing as part of your product market fit validation, you're often hearing what you want to hear.
Ramanujam on product market pricing fit Watch at 12:36

His example is a headset. Ask someone if they like it, and they say yes. Ask if they like it at a set price, and you get a very different talk (watch at 12:21).

Timing

Have the price talk before you build

Ramanujam says you do not get to choose whether you talk price with buyers, only when. You can do it after launch, when the product is done, or early, while you can still change it (watch at 14:39). First Round summed up his advice in four words: price before product (watch at 14:30).

No stage is too early. With only an idea, check whether someone would pay. Then repeat the check as you build, so your read on price is sharper by launch (watch at 15:21).

  • Porsche tested the Cayenne before it drew one.

    Before a blueprint existed, Porsche asked buyers if they wanted a Porsche SUV and would pay for it. Then it tested every feature with buyers, so a big cup holder went in and a six-speed manual went out (watch at 17:03).

  • A marketplace dropped its team favorite.

    The team's top idea showed buyers which Facebook friends had bought from the same seller. No group of buyers would pay for it. Some liked it but would not pay. Others did not want friends to see what they bought (watch at 20:18).

You cannot prioritize a product roadmap without having a willingness to pay conversation.
Ramanujam on deciding what to build Watch at 21:40

The talks also show which few features buyers pay for. Ramanujam has a rule for finding them, and it has its own page: his 20/80 rule.

The price talk

How to ask buyers what they will pay

Chapter 4 of the book covers this talk. If you read one chapter, Ramanujam says, read that one (watch at 24:23). The first rule is to never ask a buyer how much you should charge. That is your job, and the answers are useless (watch at 24:34).

Instead, give the pitch you would give after launch. Show the value first, then ask about price (watch at 28:11). Pick the question by how far along you are.

  1. 1

    With only an idea, ask if they would pay.

    If they say no, ask why. Ask why after a yes as well, and they will repeat the value they heard. Those words belong in your sales copy (watch at 32:26).

  2. 2

    With a product to show, ask for three prices.

    Ask which price feels acceptable, which feels expensive and which is far too expensive. Across many buyers, look for the point where lots of them switch to expensive (watch at 26:43).

  3. 3

    With no number in mind, compare to a tool they use.

    Ask a buyer to score you against a tool like Salesforce, first on value and then on price. A score above the tool says you can charge more than it does (watch at 25:36).

  4. 4

    With a list of features, ask for the most and least important.

    Show six of your features. Ask which one they must have and which one they would not pay for. Change the set and ask again until the whole list is ranked (watch at 30:28).

  5. 5

    Close to launch, run shopping tests.

    Show full plans with prices. Change the features and the prices, and watch which plan they pick or whether they pick none (watch at 31:03).

If they do say no, the most important question to ask is why.
Ramanujam on a buyer who says no Watch at 13:48

Rahul Vohra read the book and used the three price questions to set the price of Superhuman, his email app, Ramanujam says (watch at 27:47). How Vohra ran his survey is on the page about Van Westendorp pricing at Superhuman.

Who to ask: if you sell to companies, talk to the 20 to 30 customers that bring most of your sales (watch at 37:34). If 20 people tell you the idea is bad, he says it is bad. Patrick Campbell adds one more group once you have users: people who do not use your product yet. Your users are used to today's price, and people who have never paid it are not (watch at 17:55).

Segments

Build one product for each group of buyers

Most teams build segments from personas, and Ramanujam says that gets it wrong. Two rich men over 70 who live in British castles could be Charles and Ozzy Osbourne. They need very different things (watch at 40:11).

A segment is a group that needs, values and will pay for the same things. Water is free at a fountain, costs money in a bottle and costs more in a hotel minibar. It is the same water, packed for different needs (watch at 40:58). His test for a real segment is whether you act differently toward it, in the product you build, the message and the sales pitch (watch at 43:12).

You do not need a product for every segment on day one. Use the early price talks to learn how many segments there are and how big each one is. Then build for one first and add the others later (watch at 45:50).

Packaging

Sort features into leaders, fillers and killers

Plans and bundles are how you sell to each segment. Ramanujam sorts what goes in them with a fast food meal (watch at 56:40).

  • Leaders.

    The reason people buy, like the burger in the meal. A feature that more than half your buyers want is a leader (watch at 58:22).

  • Fillers.

    The fries and the drink. Many buyers who came for the burger will pay a little more to get them in a meal (watch at 56:53).

  • Killers.

    Coffee would make the meal worth less to most buyers, so it stays out of the bundle. Sell an item like that on its own, as an add-on, to the few who want it badly (watch at 57:21).

Don't give too much away in your entry-level product.
Ramanujam on the cheapest plan Watch at 80:01

If most buyers pick your cheapest plan, it gives too much away. Move features up so most buyers land on the middle plan. People tend to avoid the two ends, which he calls the compromise effect (watch at 80:12).

Pricing model

Decide how you charge before how much

How you charge is way more important than how much you charge.
Ramanujam on the pricing model Watch at 60:00

His example is Michelin. It made a truck tire that lasted longer, but truckers would not pay more per tire. So Michelin charged per mile driven. Truckers liked paying as they drove, and could pass the cost on to their own clients (watch at 60:39).

He makes the choice in three steps. First pick the model: subscription, pay as you go or free with paid upgrades. Then pick the unit you charge on. Then pick the structure, such as a flat fee that turns into a usage charge (watch at 69:40).

A subscription fits when buyers want bills they can plan for, or when use is rare but the value goes on, like identity theft cover. Pay as you go fits when buyers want to start small, or when you can track the value and buyers agree with the count (watch at 64:05).

His test for a pricing model is to offer the same total price in two forms, such as a flat fee or a smaller fee plus a charge per seat. Then see which form buyers pick, since that shows which model to use. On Lenny's Podcast he said he has never seen buyers call the two a tie (watch at 71:16).

He also says there are only three pricing strategies, and you should pick one and build the business around it. His examples are Apple, which starts high and lowers the price over time, and Amazon, which prices low to win on volume. He puts Microsoft between the two (Lenny's Podcast, 2022, watch at 53:50).

Pricing low just to grow is a mistake unless your business is built for it, as Amazon is (watch at 54:40).

  • To pick what you charge per, such as per seat or per use, see Patrick Campbell's value metric. Campbell puts that choice ahead of the price itself (watch at 20:52).
  • For an AI product, Ramanujam's AI pricing 2x2 helps you pick between charging per seat, per use or per result.

Framing

Pitch benefits, and frame the price

If you pitch features, you're not talking value.
Ramanujam on how to pitch Watch at 72:46

One sign you pitch features: you are excited about every part of the product. SmugMug used to list features on its plan page. It rewrote the page around benefits, such as selling photos online, and changed nothing in the product (watch at 73:30).

The book also has a chapter on how buyers judge a price by feel as well as math, which he calls behavioral pricing (watch at 76:32). Four of the moves he names:

  • A decoy plan.

    A pricey plan that few people buy makes the plan next to it look like a good deal (watch at 78:26).

  • Pennies a day.

    A price shown per day can feel smaller than the same price shown per month (watch at 81:14).

  • Razor and blades.

    Charge little up front and earn on what buyers use later, like a cheap printer with costly ink (watch at 82:34).

  • The Panini effect.

    Show your products as a sticker album with empty spots, and buyers want to fill it in (watch at 83:43).

How to apply it

How to use the method before you launch

  1. 1

    Read chapter 4 first.

    That is Ramanujam's own advice for where to start: learn that pricing has a method, then read the chapter on the price talk and run it (watch at 39:04).

  2. 2

    List who you will talk to.

    Before launch, the founder runs these talks one on one (watch at 33:52). In B2B, aim for 20 to 30 accounts.

  3. 3

    Pitch, then ask.

    Give the pitch you would give after launch. Ask if they would pay and why, then ask for the three prices.

  4. 4

    Sort your features.

    Rank them by asking which one buyers must have and which one they would not pay for. Mark the leaders, fillers and killers, and build the leaders first.

  5. 5

    Pick the model, then the number.

    Choose subscription, pay as you go or a mix. Then choose the unit you charge on. Set the price last.

  6. 6

    Check it again.

    Revisit the price at least every six months, and each time you add a plan or new features (watch at 38:20).

Limits

Where the method needs care

  • A yes is not a sale.

    Ramanujam says a buyer who rates a product 5 out of 5 is still only 30 to 50% sure to buy (Lenny's Podcast, 2022, watch at 28:55). A no, he says, tends to stay a no for months (watch at 13:28).

  • Not every operator tests price before launch.

    Alex Hormozi finds the price by selling. He raises it by 20% after every five sales until fewer people buy (his 2024 blueprint video, watch at 41:06). His live version is the gasp pricing test.

Where experts disagree

Where operators disagree: should you pitch before you ask about price?

Madhavan Ramanujam

says to give buyers the pitch you would give after launch, then ask if they would pay. A no is useful. Ask why, and the answer tells you what to build or change.

Rob Fitzpatrick

says a pitch ruins the talk, because people answer it with compliments and polite opinions. Ask about their life and what they already do about the problem, not about your idea.

Both want the product and the way it makes money built together. They split on how to ask. Use Fitzpatrick's questions first, to learn if the problem is real. Use Ramanujam's once you have something to price, and give more weight to a no than to a yes.

Sources: Ramanujam on Lenny's Podcast (watch at 13:31 and 32:26). Fitzpatrick on pitching (watch at 21:01) and on building the product and the business model together (watch at 8:58). His full method is on the Mom Test page.

The sources

Where Ramanujam explains the method

We checked each quote on this page against Ramanujam's own recordings on November 17, 2026. Each link opens at the minute he says it.

Lenny's Podcast, July 27, 2025

Pricing your AI product: Lessons from 400+ companies and 50 unicorns | Madhavan Ramanujam.

The NFX Podcast, September 4, 2025

How AI is Forcing Startups to Rethink Pricing with Madhavan Ramanujam | Ep. 5 The NFX Podcast.

Wiley published the book in May 2016 (see Wiley's page).

Stuck on a real call of your own? Gavel answers startup questions with what a named founder did, and links to the minute they said it. Ask Gavel free

New experts every week

Know when the next expert lands.

Gavel adds new operators to the database every week, each one with cited frameworks you can check and a note on where they disagree with the others. You found this page by searching. Get the next one by email instead.

Latest: Ethan Smith on Answer Engine Optimization

One email a week, only when new experts shipped. Unsubscribe with one click. We never sell or share email.

Related frameworks